guthixpicks has a total of 14 completed MLB picks the last 60-days.
* Return on Investment (ROI) figures above represent potential returns based on a $100 per unit risk amount. Please note that past results do not guarantee or imply future performance.
39 DAYS AGO
SUN, SEP 27, 2026
2:30 PM ET
LEAGUE: MLB
PICK MADE ON 9/27/2026 AT 2:12 PM ET
PICK GRADED ON 9/27/2026 AT 5:32 PM ET
39 DAYS AGO
SUN, SEP 27, 2026
3:05 PM ET
LEAGUE: MLB
PICK MADE ON 9/27/2026 AT 2:14 PM ET
PICK GRADED ON 9/27/2026 AT 6:31 PM ET
47 DAYS AGO
SAT, SEP 19, 2026
4:10 PM ET
LEAGUE: MLB
Philadelphia Phillies ML +110 Pick: Philadelphia Phillies Moneyline +110 The Phillies are getting plus money here, which gives this play value compared with simply taking the +1.5 run line. At +110, we’re getting a favorable price on Philadelphia to win outright rather than paying a heavy favorite price on the other side. I also prefer the Phillies ML over the total in this matchup because the moneyline gives us a clear path: Philadelphia just needs to win the game. Bet: Phillies ML +110 Confidence: 7/10 Risk level: Medium Final call: Phillies ML +110
PICK MADE ON 9/19/2026 AT 1:28 PM ET
PICK GRADED ON 9/19/2026 AT 8:02 PM ET
47 DAYS AGO
SAT, SEP 19, 2026
6:40 PM ET
LEAGUE: MLB
PICK MADE ON 9/19/2026 AT 1:29 PM ET
PICK GRADED ON 9/19/2026 AT 9:34 PM ET
47 DAYS AGO
SAT, SEP 19, 2026
7:05 PM ET
LEAGUE: MLB
Toronto Blue Jays ML +100 Pick: Toronto Blue Jays Moneyline +100 Toronto is being offered at essentially even money, which makes this an attractive price in a matchup where the market has the game relatively close. I prefer the Blue Jays ML +100 over the run line because we don't need Toronto to win by multiple runs. We simply need them to win the game, while getting a plus-money return. The price is the biggest reason I like this play. At +100, we're not paying a premium for the favorite. Bet: Blue Jays ML +100 Confidence: 6.5/10 Risk level: Medium Final call: Toronto Blue Jays ML +100
PICK MADE ON 9/19/2026 AT 1:31 PM ET
PICK GRADED ON 9/19/2026 AT 10:04 PM ET
53 DAYS AGO
SUN, SEP 13, 2026
1:37 PM ET
LEAGUE: MLB
Toronto Blue Jays ML -144 Pick: Toronto Blue Jays Moneyline -144 Confidence: 7.5/10 — Strong Play I’m taking the Toronto Blue Jays ML at -144 as my third and final play. Toronto has the starting-pitching advantage with Dylan Cease, and I believe that gives the Blue Jays the edge in this matchup. At -144, the price is reasonable enough to back Toronto on the moneyline without needing to rely on the run line. I prefer the moneyline over Toronto -1.5 because this is a matchup where I’m looking for Toronto to win, not necessarily win by multiple runs. The goal is to take the stronger side while keeping the required margin to a minimum.
PICK MADE ON 9/13/2026 AT 1:33 PM ET
PICK GRADED ON 9/13/2026 AT 5:35 PM ET
53 DAYS AGO
SUN, SEP 13, 2026
1:40 PM ET
LEAGUE: MLB
Houston Astros ML +114 Pick: Houston Astros Moneyline +114 Confidence: 7.5/10 — Strong Play I’m taking the Houston Astros ML at +114 as one of my strongest value plays on the board. Houston is getting plus money in a matchup where I believe they have a legitimate chance to win outright. The combination of the +114 price and Hayden Wesneski’s recent pitching form gives the Astros enough value for me to back them rather than lay the price with Tampa Bay. At +114, Houston doesn’t need to dominate — they simply need to win the game often enough to make the underdog price profitable. I also prefer the moneyline over the +1.5 run line because the plus-money payout gives us better value for taking Houston outright.
PICK MADE ON 9/13/2026 AT 1:31 PM ET
PICK GRADED ON 9/13/2026 AT 4:35 PM ET
53 DAYS AGO
SUN, SEP 13, 2026
4:10 PM ET
LEAGUE: MLB
Texas Rangers ML +114 Pick: Texas Rangers Moneyline +114 Confidence: 8/10 — Best Bet I’m taking the Texas Rangers ML at +114 as my top value play. Texas is getting plus money in a matchup where I believe the game is much closer to a coin flip than the odds suggest. At +114, we only need the Rangers to win a little over 46% of the time to justify the price, giving us a favorable risk-to-reward setup. I prefer the moneyline over the +1.5 run line because the plus-money price gives us enough value to take Texas outright rather than paying a heavy price for the extra run. Final Pick: Texas Rangers ML +114 Confidence: 8/10
PICK MADE ON 9/13/2026 AT 1:29 PM ET
PICK GRADED ON 9/13/2026 AT 8:01 PM ET
54 DAYS AGO
SAT, SEP 12, 2026
1:35 PM ET
LEAGUE: MLB
New York Mets ML +139 The Mets ML +139 is my value play on today's board. New York is getting a very attractive plus-money price despite having Zac Thornton on the mound with a solid 3.53 ERA. The Mets have also been swinging the bat extremely well recently, leading MLB in runs during the first part of September and coming off a sweep of the Marlins. The matchup against Gerrit Cole is not as intimidating as the name suggests. Cole has been vulnerable to the long ball recently, including allowing four home runs in his most recent start against San Diego. That gives the Mets' offense an opportunity to keep this game close and potentially win outright. At +139, I believe the Mets are being priced as too much of an underdog. I don't need New York to dominate—I just need them to win more often than the price implies. The pick: New York Mets ML +139 Confidence: 7/10 — STRONG PLAY
PICK MADE ON 9/12/2026 AT 1:12 PM ET
PICK GRADED ON 9/12/2026 AT 4:34 PM ET
54 DAYS AGO
SAT, SEP 12, 2026
4:10 PM ET
LEAGUE: MLB
Los Angeles Dodgers -1.5 (-108) The Dodgers -1.5 is my Best Bet on today’s board. Los Angeles comes into this matchup in excellent form, riding an eight-game winning streak. Tyler Glasnow gets the start for the Dodgers with a strong 3.12 ERA, giving Los Angeles the clear pitching advantage over Miami’s Tyler Phillips. The Dodgers also have the deeper and more dangerous lineup, and I expect their offense to put consistent pressure on Miami throughout the game. At -108, the -1.5 run line offers significantly better value than laying the heavier price on the Dodgers moneyline. The pick: Dodgers -1.5 (-108) Confidence: 7.5/10 — BEST BET
PICK MADE ON 9/12/2026 AT 1:11 PM ET
PICK GRADED ON 9/12/2026 AT 7:35 PM ET
54 DAYS AGO
SAT, SEP 12, 2026
8:10 PM ET
LEAGUE: MLB
Texas Rangers ML +112 The Rangers ML +112 is my value play on today’s board. Texas is coming off a rough 9-1 loss to Arizona, but I’m willing to look past Friday’s result rather than chase the Diamondbacks after a blowout. The Rangers still have enough offensive ability to compete in this matchup, and at +112 we’re getting plus-money value instead of paying a premium on Arizona. Kumar Rocker gets the start for Texas against Brandon Pfaadt. Pfaadt has been the better pitcher this season with a 3.53 ERA compared with Rocker’s 4.61, so this is not a matchup where I expect Texas to dominate. However, the price is what makes the Rangers interesting. At +112, I believe the Rangers have enough paths to win this game to justify taking the underdog price. We don't need Texas to be the better team overall—we need them to win often enough for the plus-money price to have value.
PICK MADE ON 9/12/2026 AT 1:15 PM ET
PICK GRADED ON 9/13/2026 AT 12:09 AM ET
59 DAYS AGO
MON, SEP 7, 2026
1:05 PM ET
LEAGUE: MLB
Philadelphia Phillies ML -160 ⭐ Strong Play — 7/10 Confidence Pick: Philadelphia Phillies ML (-160) The Phillies are in a strong bounce-back spot Monday against the Braves, and the biggest reason I like Philadelphia is the starting-pitching matchup. Philadelphia sends Jesús Luzardo to the mound. Luzardo is having an excellent season at 13-5 with a 3.02 ERA and 209 strikeouts, and his recent form has been particularly impressive. Since the beginning of August, he has allowed no more than two earned runs in six consecutive starts, posting a 1.32 ERA over that stretch. Atlanta counters with Grant Holmes, who enters at 9-5 with a 3.62 ERA and 104 strikeouts. Holmes is capable of pitching well, but the overall matchup still favors Luzardo and Philadelphia. The Phillies also have plenty of motivation. After Sunday's heartbreaking 5-4 loss to Atlanta, Philadelphia needs a win Monday to salvage a split of this four-game series. The Braves currently hold the advantage in the NL East, making these head-to-head games particularly important. I also prefer the moneyline at -160 rather than laying -1.5 runs. Philadelphia simply needs to win the game, and with Luzardo on the mound at home, I don't want to require a multi-run victory.
PICK MADE ON 9/7/2026 AT 10:40 AM ET
PICK GRADED ON 9/7/2026 AT 3:32 PM ET
59 DAYS AGO
MON, SEP 7, 2026
2:10 PM ET
LEAGUE: MLB
⚾ Chicago Cubs ML +110 ⭐ Good Play — 7/10 Confidence Pick: Chicago Cubs Moneyline (+110) The Cubs are getting plus money Monday against the Brewers in a matchup that looks much closer than the moneyline suggests. Chicago sends Matthew Boyd to the mound. Boyd enters at 8-3 with a 4.05 ERA and 1.23 WHIP, while Milwaukee counters with Robert Gasser, who is 4-5 with a 4.57 ERA and 1.29 WHIP. The starting-pitching matchup gives Chicago a legitimate chance to win this game outright. The Cubs also bring one of the strongest offenses in baseball into this matchup. Chicago leads MLB in runs scored and home runs, and the Cubs have produced a .771 OPS with 201 home runs and 768 runs entering the series. Milwaukee deserves respect—the Brewers are 88-56 and own the best record in the matchup—but the current market is still asking us to take Chicago at plus money. Current books have generally had the Cubs around +105 to +113, with Milwaukee around -117 to -125. That makes our +110 a playable price. This is also an important series for Chicago. The Cubs currently occupy a top Wild Card position, while Milwaukee leads the NL Central. After splitting their previous four-game series, Chicago now gets another opportunity against the division leader.
PICK MADE ON 9/7/2026 AT 10:43 AM ET
PICK GRADED ON 9/7/2026 AT 5:06 PM ET
59 DAYS AGO
MON, SEP 7, 2026
10:05 PM ET
LEAGUE: MLB
⚾ Toronto Blue Jays -1.5 (-117) ⭐ Best Bet — 8/10 Confidence Pick: Toronto Blue Jays -1.5 (-117) The Blue Jays are in an excellent spot Monday night against the Athletics, and the biggest reason is the starting-pitching advantage. Toronto sends Dylan Cease to the mound. Cease enters at 10-5 with a 2.25 ERA, 1.04 WHIP and 221 strikeouts. He is coming off a dominant outing against Cleveland in which he threw six scoreless innings without allowing a walk. Oakland counters with Jacob Lopez, who enters at 6-4 with a 4.71 ERA and 1.46 WHIP. That's a significant gap compared with Cease, particularly when we're getting Toronto at a reasonable run-line price rather than laying the heavy moneyline. Toronto also enters this game having won four straight before Sunday's loss, and the Blue Jays remain firmly in the AL Wild Card race. The market has Toronto around -210 on the moneyline, while the run line is around -1.5, making our -1.5 (-117) a much better way to attack the favorite than paying close to -200 on the straight moneyline. 🔑 Why I Like It Major starting-pitcher advantage: Cease's 2.25 ERA vs. Lopez's 4.71 ERA. Elite strikeout ability: Cease has 221 strikeouts this season. Toronto is motivated: The Jays are battling for an AL Wild Card position. Better value than the ML: Instead of laying roughly -200 or more, we're getting the run line at -117. Price is playable: We don't need Toronto simply to win—we need them to win by 2+ runs. 🎯 Final Verdict TORONTO BLUE JAYS -1.5 (-117) Confidence: 8/10 ⭐ BEST BET OF THE DAY This is the type of favorite I want: strong starting-pitching advantage + meaningful playoff motivation + a much better price through the run line.
PICK MADE ON 9/7/2026 AT 10:38 AM ET
PICK GRADED ON 9/8/2026 AT 3:04 AM ET